The RSU Withholding Gap: Why Your Best Vesting Year Can End With Your Biggest Tax Surprise
Two equity packages, two employers, one household tax bill — and November is the last good month to see it coming.
Every year, a familiar pattern plays out in Silicon Valley households. The stock did well. The vests were bigger than expected. Taxes were “taken care of” automatically, because shares were sold to cover them at every vest. Then, in April, a five-figure balance due arrives, sometimes with an underpayment penalty attached.
Nothing went wrong, exactly. The system worked as designed. The problem is that the system was designed for a much simpler tax picture than the one most dual-equity households actually have.
Who They Are
Meet Priya and David, a couple in their mid-40s. Priya is a Director at a public technology firm, while David is a Principal Engineer at another tech company. Together, their base compensation is around $480,000. In 2026, driven by a strong run-up in Priya’s corporate stock, their combined RSU vestings reached approximately $420,000, pushing their total household W-2 earnings close to $900,000.
They’re disciplined savers with a clean balance sheet. They max their 401(k)s, they don’t carry consumer debt, and they assumed that sell-to-cover at each vesting meant their taxes were handled. Like many two-earner households, they also filled out their W-4s separately, years ago, and never revisited them.
The Problem: “Withheld” Is Not the Same as “Paid in Full”
When RSUs vest, employers typically withhold federal income tax at the flat 22% supplemental rate (37% only applies to supplemental wages above $1 million from a single employer in a year). That 22% is a statutory default, not an estimate of what you actually owe.
For Priya and David, the vested income sits at the very top of their household income, and at that level, their federal marginal brackets are 32%, 35%, and 37%. Every dollar of RSU income is being withheld at 22% but taxed at well above it.
What the Projection Uncovered
The federal RSU gap. Layering $420,000 of vest income on top of their salaries, the blended federal rate on those vests works out to roughly 35%. Withholding at 22% leaves a shortfall of more than $50,000 on the vests alone.
The two-earner W-4 problem. Each employer withheld on salary as if that salary were the household’s only income, using the lower brackets twice. Because neither W-4 accounted for the other spouse, their withholding was also light, adding several thousand dollars to the gap.
The Additional Medicare Tax mismatch. The 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax applies to a married couple’s combined wages above $250,000, but each employer only starts withholding it once that individual employee passes $200,000. The difference is small, but it’s another line that quietly doesn’t reconcile.
California, by contrast, is closer. California’s 10.23% supplemental withholding rate on equity compensation lands much nearer to its actual state marginal rate, so the state gap was modest. The real exposure was federal.
Safe harbor was not met. The full-year federal projection showed a balance due approaching $60,000. And because 2025 was a smaller vesting year, they hadn’t withheld enough to meet the safe-harbor test either 110% of the prior year’s tax for households with AGI above $150,000, or 90% of the current year’s. That meant an underpayment penalty on top of the bill.
Concentration was compounding it. Most of their liquid net worth outside retirement accounts was in Priya’s company stock, the same stock whose run-up created the problem. The household’s cash to pay the April bill would likely come from selling that stock, under time pressure, at whatever price it happened to be in April.
The Plan Built
Fix it through withholding, not just an estimated payment. This is the detail most people miss. Federal withholding is treated as if it were paid evenly throughout the year, no matter when it actually comes out of a paycheck. An estimated payment counts only from the date it’s made. By increasing withholding on their remaining November and December paychecks, Priya and David can close the shortfall and retroactively cover the earlier quarters, which an estimated payment on January 15 cannot do.
Fund it by selling recently vested shares. RSU shares carry a cost basis equal to their value on the vest date, so selling recently vested shares typically triggers little or no additional gain. Using those shares to cover the extra withholding meets the tax obligation and reduces Priya’s concentration at the same time.
Rewrite both W-4s as a household. Update each W-4 to reflect the other spouse’s income so salary withholding reflects their combined bracket going forward.
Elect higher RSU withholding where available. Some equity plan administrators allow employees to elect a higher withholding rate on vests; many don’t. Where it’s possible, raising it removes most of the gap at the source. Where it isn’t, the plan sets aside a fixed percentage of every vest into a dedicated tax reserve account.
Project quarterly, not annually. A tax projection now runs after each major vest, so the household sees the year-end number in May and August instead of discovering it in April.
| NUA: It Doesn’t Apply to RSUs Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) comes up often in equity-comp conversations, so it’s worth clearing up. NUA is a tax treatment for employer stock held inside a qualified retirement plan, such as a 401(k) or ESOP, and distributed in a lump sum after a qualifying event like separation from service. In that narrow case, the stock’s growth can be taxed at long-term capital gains rates instead of ordinary income. RSUs never qualify. RSU shares are taxed as ordinary income the day they vest, and they land in a regular brokerage account with a cost basis equal to their market value on the vest date. From there, any further gain or loss is a capital gain or loss, short- or long-term depending on how long you hold. There is no NUA election to make, and no retirement-plan wrapper that changes the math. If someone suggests NUA as a solution for your RSUs, it’s worth getting a second opinion. |
What Changed
The tax bill itself didn’t go away; the income was real, and so is the tax on it. What changed is everything around it. We eliminated the penalty exposure before year-end. The cash came from a planned diversification sale, not a forced April sale. And going forward, the household’s withholding reflects how their income actually works: two salaries, two equity packages, and one combined bracket.
For dual-equity households, the withholding gap is less a mistake than a blind spot. Each employer sees only its own employee. By default, no one is looking at the household.
If This Sounds Familiar
If your household has had a strong vesting year and you haven’t run a full-year projection since the summer, November is the month to do it while there are still paychecks left to adjust. I’m always glad to compare notes with people working through equity compensation and household tax planning. You can reach me at Randa@RadiantWealthPlanning.com.
These stories are based on real-life scenarios. Names and details have been changed. This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice.
Welcome to our blog where we share tips and advice on all topics that help women meet their financial goals.